Products

A thick New York-style cookie with a light, crisp edge and soft center, made with toasted coconut, toasted pecans, dried cherries, creamy white chocolate chips, and a cherry preserve center for a cozy cherry cobbler-inspired bite.

Made with European butter, fine Belgian chocolate, and premium semi-sweet chocolate chips, our vanilla-based dough is slow-rested for 24 hours to build deeper flavor, golden buttery edges, and a soft, indulgent bite with rich chocolate pockets throughout.

Our classic Chocolate Chip cookie, now in a bite-sized NYC Mini. Made with European butter, fine Belgian dark chocolate, and premium semi-sweet chocolate chips, each batch undergoes a 48-hour process to develop a rich flavor, golden buttery edges, and a soft, indulgent texture that Big Sweet Tasty is known for.

Each NYC Mini is portioned at 1 oz and packed in a resealable bag for easy snacking and freshness. Available in 6-count or 12-count bags.

Our Chocolate Chip Pecan cookie takes everything you love about our Chocolate Chip cookie and adds the rich, buttery crunch of toasted pecans.

Made with European butter, a vanilla-based dough, premium semi-sweet chocolate chips, and toasted pecans, this cookie is slow-rested for 24 hours to build deeper flavor and a soft decadent texture. Every bite brings together golden buttery edges, a soft center, pockets of chocolate, and a warm nutty crunch from the pecans.

Classic, cozy, and just a little more grown-up.

Our Chocolate Peanut Butter cookie is rich, fudgy, and made for true chocolate-and-peanut-butter lovers. We start with a deep chocolate dough made with premium cocoa and European-style butter for a bold, buttery, brownie-like bite. Then we fold in Reese’s peanut butter chips for that unmistakable peanut butter sweetness and rich semi-sweet chocolate chips for chocolate in every bite. At the center is our house-made peanut butter filling, smooth, decadent, and made to bring the whole cookie together.

Our New York-Style Cookie Butter cookie combines the flavors of caramel, cinnamon, and Biscoff into a thick, delicious cookie. Made with European butter and a rich caramel-style dough, this cookie is loaded with Biscoff cookie pieces for signature spiced sweetness, buttery toffee for a sweet crunch, warm cinnamon for cozy depth, and creamy white chocolate chips for a smooth finish. At the center is a rich Biscoff cookie butter filling, and we finish it with a cookie butter drizzle for one more layer of sweet, spiced flavor.

Cookies and Cream Brownie is a thick 6 oz NYC-style cookie made with European butter, Oreo cookie pieces, house-made fudgy brownie chunks, and premium creamy white chocolate chips. With crisp buttery edges and a soft, rich center, this indulgent cookies and cream cookie is loaded with decadent flavor in every bite.

Our Lemon Vanilla Cream cookie brings together bright fresh lemon, smooth vanilla sweetness, and creamy white chocolate in one thick New York-style cookie. Made with European butter and our signature fresh lemon sugar blend, it has a bright lemon flavor balanced by sweet vanilla notes from Lemon Oreo pieces, creamy white chocolate chips, and a smooth white chocolate drizzle. It’s soft, citrusy, creamy, and just sweet enough to keep you going back for another bite.